Traditional Chinese medicine may not ten people a party

-and XiongXingJiang physicians to dispute

GaoJianZhong Shanxi institute of traditional Chinese medicine and the second hospital

China's traditional Chinese medicine reported

        "The speculative", is one of the important contents of Chinese culture, rooted in the Chinese culture cannot leave from traditional Chinese medicine "speculative". Pursue the empirical, we may do "ten people party"; Accept speculative, we can only is "ten people ten party".

        Cause and pathogenesis also belong to cause one of the party card path. If the judge party card only confine to the "symptoms, signs" distinguish, this directly affect the curative effect of the license, also can let the certificate of traditional Chinese medicine go narrower more.

        Nearly read on 16 August in Mr. XiongXingJiang to convey the Chinese medicine should be able to "ten people party" "penny, some ideas can't agree.

        "Ten people party" was an ideal state

        We hope to do "ten people a party", so it is easy to learn, inheritance of the traditional Chinese medicine, also be helpful for batch of traditional Chinese medicine has group. But the reality is, "ten people ten party", today is, history is also.

        "Chinese should be able to ten people party" (hereinafter referred to as "Chinese") a text of the "ten people ten party" reason boils down to "the root of the problem lies in the clinical prescription medication way of thinking," this seems not wrong, "anyone's guess", the different ways of thinking, directly will lead to the different prescription medicine. But to this way of thinking are limited to "syndrome differentiation and treatment according to the pathogenesis of prescription medication thinking" is necessarily appropriate.

        The object of medical research is "people", is "the living", the person's complexity is far from our existing knowledge can figure. Face to face with a failed to crack "complex", aluminum "empirical thinking of" to intervene, treatment, we found that the medicine and the doctor was largely incompetent.

        "The speculative", is one of the important contents of Chinese culture, rooted in the Chinese culture in traditional Chinese medicine, is unable to leave "the speculative". The eastern civilization and western civilization achievements in traditional Chinese medicine and western medicine for their respective, traditional Chinese medicine focused on speculative, western medicine focused on empirical, both have many complementary space, can say this is the human f. If we all go to the medical evidence, no speculative, humans can only have a kind of medicine, traditional Chinese medicine is also not exist.

        Pursue the empirical, we may do "ten people party"; Accept speculative, we can only is "ten people ten party".

        "Treatise on febrile diseases" can say is typical of the corresponding party card. But in the preface also mention: "although the disease, the failed to do very can see disease, if can know the source for the set more than half, think will do." Perhaps the author (or write the preface to think in the book also just cited party card corresponding just, after more need to do is scholars "thinking". The theory, are not all square with syndrome of one same, if there is a lot of the items mentioned "and", "not", a part of the provisions in the writing marked with a certificate of "try party planning" record. Now that is "but", "try", there is uncertainty, it is possible to "ten people ten party", not "ten people party". If really can do party card one-to-one, ten party, typhoid school also won't appear internal faction lining.

        Clinical experience for many years, the author special praise gerda creek in the more than due of "cite Mr. Luo too without the analogy:" with this disease, as methods to tear open the old house, the new house, gather together, no longer than a wood material by the hand of the potter's, who can be used?" Potter's different, since the new house are also different.

        Bian party card and authentication should not lacerate pathogenesis

        The author identity "Chinese" in the article mentioned "finally the card for or assigned to specific party identification card, namely party card correspondence, distinguishes party card differentiation." This is a Chinese clinical every one of them can feel. But the author does not agree with the judge party card use and cause apart, with pathogenesis use up.

        Bian party card can have different paths, cause also belong to the pathogenesis of one of the distinguishing party card path. If the judge party card only confine to the "symptoms, signs" distinguish, this directly affect the curative effect of the license, also can let the certificate of traditional Chinese medicine go narrower more.

        Every summer, a lot of children appetite is significantly reduced, parents is very anxious. This kind of children to the clinic, in addition to "the food reduce" the complaints, ZhuZheng outside, can do not have any available for distinguishing party card the signs and symptoms. If not from "the pathogenesis of our failure is out specific party card. Of course we make "the child is normal, do not need to be treated for the conclusion of" seems to be not the right, at least to diagnosis of parents are reluctant to accept. The author often from the "mechanism" of speculative, choose white atractylodes (or cangzhu), agkistrodon, endothelium corneum with born hawthorn (or coke hawthorn) 3 ~ 4 flavour Chinese traditional medicine, appetizing luck spleen, can let children increase appetite. Similar clinical problem should be many.

        In fact, we each person is not possible clinical completely not bian pathogenesis. To distinguish the big bear gas decoction syndrome and white tiger decoction syndrome, we first will judge whether "stomach home reality", have without "in real hot", have without "setting real," and so on, this kind of all belong to the pathogenesis "category.

        Party card can only to a certain extent norms

        "Chinese" in the article points out that: "if we can grasp the party card, medicine disease syndrome in the law, and accurate identification certificate, then face recognition, the same patients' ten people a party in the border of 'card can be realized."

        Can do it "accurately identify recognition", actually refers to the standard, it is a party to the standardization of the card.

        "Chinese" in the article also mentioned: "symptoms and signs the nuances of the clinical know certificate is used square root." Also is the standard each party of the corresponding symptoms, signs.

        The surface looks, party card norms can solve many problems, such as traditional Chinese medicine inheritance and everbright difficult. In fact, party card can only on certain level standard, too much pursuit party card norms, exaggerated party card standard role, is a direct result of traditional Chinese medicine clinical and the killing of scholars "spiritual", but unfavorable to improve clinical level.

        Mention party card and the medicine syndrome of standard, everyone will think of two books, "treatise on febrile diseases" and cold-induced febride. In fact, only speak "card", don't tell "reason", how many people just learn the two books can be a good Chinese clinical person? How much more, of the two books is also speak "reason", such as the camp with four natures, who gas, etc.

        YiXiaoEr fever along while, strong, coating on the yellow greasy, come on QianBanTian have have a bowel movement 1, the big shots bearing gas soup 1 agent, pouring down the three times; A old man stroke on January, shall not hunger nor thirst, tongue qualitative light dark, thin coating on the white, pulse string big, no four inverse, has four inverse soup and agent, the diet is back to normal. If according to provisions treatise on febrile disease from party card corresponding identification, children is no big bear gas decoction syndrome, the old man could not distinguish four inverse decoction syndrome. But from the drug use result analysis, children have is really big bear gas decoction syndrome, the old man is four inverse decoction syndrome. Here the process of distinguishing party card use the cause and pathogenesis, the use of the reasoning.

        Many of the growth in Chinese clinical will have such an experience: when the yourself to a long period of experience after finishing standard, suddenly found that regulate something after clinically often be new problems is broken.

        YueMeiZhong said

        "Chinese" is a text to explain that distinguishes party card is better than the cause and pathogenesis, quoted Mr YueMeiZhong a words: "(again to study treatise on febrile disease and synopsis of golden chamber) see the syndrome was never pathology, not to say the prescriptions in an objective, argues, medicinal properties for healing stone to remove disease. Its plain experimental academic, real approximation of the science found the instrument is remove disease. And grinds only" the daughter of the tang dynasty, the platform outside of the book, a simple and practical study of the party, straight up, fruit of zhongjing's proper, also can be like a drum Fu effect." This passage is only the first stage of learning YueMeiZhong sir medical understanding of, and the third phase is to realize "clinging to put to the living and the dead party, even if the comprehensive and post to the Chinese and foreign, also has to avoid the disadvantages XiaoZuShiLv." In fact, Mr. YueMeiZhong also said something like: "in ancient physicians, in addition, the more highly, outside of zhongjing's east walls." "I am pleased with the zhongjing's prescriptions, also pleased with the east of herbal walls, especially into old age in the treatment of some chronic illnesses and some senile disease, use the east of herbal walls, nimble, and returns the light." (see "the YueMeiZhong YiHua set") and the study of the walls, and said, the nakedness of spleen and stomach, internal injuries related to hide gas when, lift as well as the method, the ban, disease, the ban when, etc, and distinguishing party card drug significantly different.

        Maybe, some scholars think, Mr. YueMeiZhong here only refer to the east of herbal use walls and walls party can also cause the party card use, not to use the theory of walls. In fact, in the LiDongYuan teacher ZhangYuanSu "ancient FangJin disease that can" know influence, in the book are all homemade party, for example, the party aims to argue. Clinical use each a prescription actually use the method of the walls and not the east side walls, the need for users "examine the time, the judge by the judge, the disease and then drug use" (" the taste of "). Israel in reason, of course, are formed "reason" participation in the party card.

        Jinyuan medical prosperity of thinking

        In the long history of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), "she FengQi and schools of thought contend" the formation of the situation, began in jinyuan medicine. And the prosperity of the millions of medical background is "" and agent pharmacopoeia of the book also, can according to for prosecution, namely the application card......" "The government keep the door that law, the medical industry, the thought of the sick relies on life, the world of learning made to ChengSu." (the JuFang play "). Jinyuan medical prosperity is really one of the principal means of the "science" is introduced to Chinese medicine (TCM), construct and perfect the system of TCM theory, the traditional Chinese medicine by the heavy "art" high to heavy "reason" level. We should not think heavy "reason" is medical regression.